Supervisors play a critical role in shaping the success of both their team and the organization. They are responsible for managing daily operations, ensuring agents meet performance targets, and maintaining high levels of customer satisfaction. However, even the most well-intentioned supervisors can fall into habits that unintentionally hinder their team’s growth and productivity.
In this blog, we’ll explore 12 bad habits that many call center supervisors fall into. From micromanaging to failing to lead by example, these common mistakes can lead to disengaged agents, low morale, and poor customer experiences. Whether you’re a seasoned supervisor or new to the role, recognizing these pitfalls is the first step toward becoming a more effective and supportive leader.
By the end of this post, you’ll identify the habits to avoid and gain actionable insights on improving your leadership style and creating a positive work environment for your team. Let’s dive in and explore how these bad habits can be overcome to unlock the full potential of your call center team.
1. Micromanaging Every Call
Micromanagement is one of the most detrimental habits a call center supervisor can develop. While the intention may be to ensure quality control, micromanaging agents during every call creates an atmosphere of distrust and undermines the agent’s confidence and autonomy.
Example: A supervisor constantly interrupts an agent’s call to offer real-time feedback or to suggest what the agent should say next. This leaves the agent feeling untrusted and anxious about making decisions, negatively impacting the call and the agent’s morale.
Solution: Instead of hovering over every call, give your agents the tools and training they need to succeed independently. Provide regular coaching sessions based on performance data and encourage agents to approach you for support when needed. Allow agents the autonomy to handle calls and solve problems in their own way, which fosters a sense of responsibility and ownership.
2. Ignoring Agent Feedback
A call center supervisor who ignores the feedback of their agents is likely to encounter frustration and disengagement within their team. Agents often have valuable insights into process improvements, customer issues, or suggestions for team dynamics that can help the call center function more efficiently.
Example: An agent proposes a change to the script that could improve customer satisfaction, but the supervisor dismisses it without exploring the idea further. This leads to the agent feeling undervalued and less likely to offer suggestions in the future.
Solution: Create a culture where feedback is encouraged and acted upon. Hold regular meetings where agents can voice their concerns or ideas for improvement. Acknowledge their input and implement viable suggestions to show that their opinions matter.
3. Playing Favorites
Favoritism can destroy team morale and create an environment of competition rather than collaboration. When supervisors give preferential treatment to certain agents, whether regarding scheduling, recognition, or workload distribution, it leads to feelings of unfairness among the team.
Example: A supervisor always gives the best shifts and the easiest calls to one agent, while others feel they are stuck with the more difficult work. Over time, this breeds resentment and affects the team’s overall cohesion.
Solution: Strive for fairness and consistency when assigning shifts, rewards, and responsibilities. Recognize your team members’ individual strengths and needs, but ensure that every agent is treated equally and has an opportunity to shine.
4. Failing to Set Clear Expectations
When supervisors fail to communicate expectations clearly, agents are left guessing what’s required of them. This lack of clarity leads to confusion, missed targets, and frustration.
Example: An agent who hasn’t been told that customer satisfaction scores are a major metric may focus too much on call duration, resulting in rushed conversations that negatively affect the customer experience.
Solution: Set clear, measurable goals from the outset. Regularly communicate performance metrics, company goals, and individual expectations so agents understand how their work directly impacts the team’s success. Regular check-ins and updates on progress can also help reinforce these expectations.
5. Avoiding Difficult Conversations
Difficult conversations, especially when addressing performance issues or personal conflicts, are a part of every supervisor’s job. However, many avoid these talks because they are uncomfortable. Avoiding these situations can allow problems to fester, leading to bigger issues down the line.
Example: A supervisor notices an agent consistently missing deadlines or displaying negative behavior but doesn’t address the issue, hoping it will improve on its own. Eventually, the agent’s performance worsens, and other team members become frustrated.
Solution: Don’t shy away from difficult conversations. Address performance issues or interpersonal conflicts promptly, but with empathy. Use these opportunities to coach agents and provide constructive feedback that helps them grow.
6. Overlooking Team Development
Neglecting your team’s professional development can lead to stagnation, low morale, and high turnover. Call center agents often feel their role is a stepping stone unless there’s a clear path for growth.
Example: A supervisor focuses only on meeting daily targets and offers no training or opportunities for agents to develop new skills. Over time, agents feel bored or frustrated with the lack of career progression.
Solution: Invest in your agents’ development by providing training, cross-training opportunities, and the chance to learn new skills. Offer clear career advancement paths and encourage agents to take on leadership roles or more challenging projects.
7. Being Unavailable for Support
A supervisor who is often unavailable or unapproachable creates a feeling of isolation among agents, particularly when they need guidance or help with escalated issues. A lack of support leads to frustration, which can affect both the quality of calls and overall morale.
Example: An agent dealing with an angry customer can’t get in touch with their supervisor for help and is forced to handle the situation alone, which could result in an unsatisfactory customer experience.
Solution: Make yourself available for your team. Be present on the floor, available via chat or messaging, and approachable when agents need guidance. Set clear expectations for when and how agents should reach out for assistance and ensure they feel supported.
8. Relying Solely on Metrics
While metrics are important, relying exclusively on them can be detrimental to understanding the full picture of an agent’s performance. Focusing solely on numbers can encourage the wrong behaviors, like rushing calls to meet speed targets at the cost of customer satisfaction.
Example: A supervisor who strictly focuses on reducing average handle time may pressure agents to end calls quickly, resulting in frustrated customers and low satisfaction scores.
Solution: Use a balanced approach. Alongside quantitative metrics, qualitative measures like customer satisfaction, first call resolution, and agent engagement are included. Provide feedback based on both types of data to ensure agents understand the importance of quality over mere numbers.
9. Lack of Recognition or Praise
Recognition is a powerful motivator in any work environment, and call centers are no exception. When agents’ hard work goes unnoticed, it can lead to disengagement and a lack of motivation.
Example: An agent consistently hits their performance targets but never receives any recognition for their efforts, while others who make a single mistake are called out. This leads to feelings of discouragement and a lack of enthusiasm for their work.
Solution: Regularly acknowledge the efforts of your agents. Publicly praise them for meeting targets, resolving complex issues, or displaying positive behavior. Celebrate small wins, not just big achievements, to keep morale high.
mySQM™ QA helps recognize agents through award points earned in real-time after a QA evaluation that is converted to dollars and redeemed at most retailers using an SQM debit card.
10. Overloading Agents with Too Much Work
A supervisor who overburdens their agents with unrealistic expectations or too much work can cause burnout, decrease productivity, and increase turnover.
Example: A supervisor assigns an agent back-to-back calls with no breaks, expecting them to maintain high performance without considering their mental and physical well-being. Eventually, the agent starts making mistakes or becomes disengaged.
Solution: Be mindful of your agents’ workload. Ensure they have enough time between calls to recover and stay productive. If additional tasks are needed, make sure to distribute the workload fairly across the team to avoid overloading any one individual.
11. Being Inconsistent with Policies
Consistency is key when enforcing policies and procedures. When a supervisor is inconsistent, it can lead to confusion, frustration, and resentment among team members.
Example: One agent is reprimanded for taking an extended break, while another is allowed to do so without consequence. This inconsistency creates tension and undermines the supervisor’s authority.
Solution: Always apply policies and procedures fairly and consistently. Communicate these expectations to your team, and ensure everyone is held to the same standards. When exceptions are made, be transparent about why they are necessary.
12. Failing to Lead by Example
Supervisors who don’t lead by example undermine their credibility and authority. When supervisors fail to demonstrate the behavior they expect from agents, it creates a disconnect and fosters a lack of respect.
Example: A supervisor who consistently arrives late to work, ignores customer service standards, or exhibits poor communication skills sends the message that these behaviors are acceptable, even though they are not.
Solution: Always model the behaviors you want to see in your team. Arrive on time, demonstrate professionalism, adhere to policies, and show respect for your team. Your actions will speak louder than your words, and agents will follow your lead.
